2022 Optimization Days

HEC Montréal, Québec, Canada, 16 — 18 May 2022

Schedule Authors My Schedule

TB4 - Multicriteria Decision Aid

May 17, 2022 03:30 PM – 05:10 PM

Location: Dutailier International (green)

Chaired by Jean-Philippe Waaub

2 Presentations

  • 03:30 PM - 03:55 PM

    Preference learning in multicriteria decision analyses: UTASTAR-T, a novel time-series-based optimization method

    • Betania Campello, presenter, UNICAMP
    • Sarah BenAmor, University of Ottawa
    • Leonardo Duarte, University of Campinas
    • Joao Romano, UNICAMP

    Multicriteria decision analysis (MCDA) methods are used in decisions involving a set of alternatives according to multiple criteria. Preference learning in MCDA infers the preferences of a decision-maker provided indirectly by him/her.They generally use a linear programming formulation to determine piecewise linear marginal value functions.

    In these methods, each criterion is associated with a single value, such as the criterion performance average in a given period of time or the criterion's last value available. Although this is appropriate in many situations, decisions are often made considering some characteristics of the criteria's time-series (summary measures such as the average and tendency). For instance, in medium- or long-term investment decisions, the tendency of the criteria is as relevant as their average.

    Thus, we propose UTASTAR-T, an extension of the well known MCDA method, UTASTAR, to learn the DM's preferences in a context where the characteristics of the time-series criteria are considered simultaneously. The proposed method was tested and validated using actual data for the assessment of ten countries, using three criteria, life expectancy at birth, education, and gross national income per capita, while taking into account the criteria’s average and tendency.

  • 03:55 PM - 04:20 PM

    MCDA decision process for strategic environmental and social assessment at the regional planning level

    • Jean-Philippe Waaub, presenter, Université du Québec à Montréal
    • Gillles Côté, President of the Federal Review Committee (COFEX)
    • Jean-François Guay, Institute of Environmental Sciences – UQAM

    An eight steps decision process are discussed. They provide interested parties with a collaborative and contributive framework to understand and organize the issues raised by the SESA to be addressed. They also provide the accountable public authorities the information needed to clarify their understanding of the problem and to make the decision.